Watch Exchange Singapore Logo

Buy, Sell, Consign or Trade Your Watches

Contact Us Now

Join Our Telegram Channel for The Latest Watch Deals! Join Now

Patek Philippe vs. Cartier: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Published on
Comparison
Patek Philippe vs. Cartier A Side-by-Side Comparison

Patek Philippe and Cartier boast a rich history and distinct approach to watchmaking. Patek Philippe is often hailed for its technical prowess and classic designs, symbolizing horological excellence and commanding tremendous price tags. 

In contrast, Cartier is known for its bold style and innovative designs, blending fine jewelry with watchmaking artistry. If put against Patek Philippe, Cartier is considered more accessible; thus, its price is much more affordable.

This comparison highlights their heritage, design, technology, innovation, and price differences to help you make an informed decision.

Heritage and History

Patek Philippe was founded by Antoni Patek and Adrien Philippe in 1839 in the heart of Geneva, Switzerland. Since then, this brand has long been associated with technical innovation and precision. These are evident in its contributions to the industry, such as the invention of the first perpetual calendar and the split-second chronograph. 

Due to how long-lasting their luxury watches are, the Patek Philippe brand has been boosted by its iconic advertising campaign; as Roberta Naas of Forbes would describe it: “You never actually own a Patek Philippe. You merely look after it for the next generation.” Thus, Patek Philippe watches became heirlooms and were passed down through generations.

On the other hand, Cartier was established in 1847 by Louis-François Cartier and his succeeding generations in Paris, France. Originally a jewelry house, Cartier ventured into watchmaking by creating the Santos watch in 1904, one of the first brand new Cartier watch specimens released at the time. It has also produced well-designed quartz watches for women in distinctive styles. The brand’s iconic Tank, Panthère, and Ballon Bleu collections are some of the things that stand out in its jewelry-making heritage.

Design Philosophy and Aesthetics

Patek Philippe watches are characterized by their refined and classic appearance. These often feature round or slightly curved cases, exuding understated elegance. 

Looking into the watch face, the dials are typically clean and uncluttered, with Roman or baton hour markers and slender hands, contributing to the watches’ timeless look. 

Meanwhile, the color palette tends to be subtle, with a preference for white, black, or silver dials. These are complemented by leather straps or metal bracelets that enhance the overall look of the timepieces.

As for Cartier watches, they are known for their distinctive, bold designs. It is more famous for its unique case shapes, such as the rectangular Tank, the square Santos, and the oval Baignoire. These are paired with dials featuring Roman numerals, blued-steel hands, and a signature guilloché style, adding a touch of elegance and intricacy. 

As for the use of color, it’s varied as it ranges from classic white to bold hues, and straps and bracelets that include metal and leather options.

Craftsmanship and Technical Excellence

Patek Philippe isn’t new regarding complications like perpetual calendars, minute repeaters, and tourbillons. Each Patek Philippe watch they produce is hand-finished, with attention to detail evident in the polished cases, hand-applied hour markers, and finely decorated movements visible through sapphire case backs. 

These are further underscored by its Patek Philippe Seal, a mark of excellence that guarantees the highest standards of craftsmanship and performance.

Cartier, while known for its design prowess, also demonstrates considerable technical skill in its watchmaking, albeit not as technically excellent as Patek Philippe’s when it comes to creating mechanically complicated watches. The brand is focused on creating innovative movements, like the mystery clock and the skeletonized movements. 

Moreover, Cartier’s craftsmanship is visible in the precise setting of gemstones, the polished finish of the cases, and the delicate engraving on the dials.

Innovations and Horological Achievements

Patek Philippe has a rich history of introducing intricate complications, like the renowned first pocket watch with a tourbillon and the development of the perpetual calendar mechanism. 

These innovations became the pathway for more technical excellence manifested along the brand’s timeline, further solidifying its reputation in the watchmaking industry.

Meanwhile, Cartier’s innovation is seen through the creation of the mystery clock, which features transparent dials with floating hands. These give the illusion that they are moving without any visible connection to the movement. 

This innovative design has been adapted in Cartier’s wristwatches, showcasing the brand’s ability to blend technical ingenuity with aesthetic elegance.

On top of that, Cartier has developed its own in-house movements, such as the Calibre de Cartier, which further demonstrates the brand’s commitment to design excellence and horological innovation.

Price, Accessibility, and Investment Opportunity

Patek Philippe

Patek Philippe is known for its meticulous handcrafting process, limited production numbers (In fact, some models are hard to get, as Nazanin Lankarani of the New York Times said), and use of high-quality materials. That said, its watches, often ranging from S$14,299 to S$790,636, are often regarded as an investment due to their ability to retain value and, in many cases, appreciate over time.

Here are some of the top Patek Philippe models and their value:

1. Nautilus 5711/1A

patek philippe mens watch 5711/1A-010

This is one of the highly sought-after stainless steel sports watches with a unique design that has seen significant appreciation in the secondary market as it retails for S$46,800 and can be sold for S$117,315 in the secondary market, as per the data found in Watch Charts.

2. Calatrava 5196J

Patek Philippe Calatrava 5196J

This watch is notable for its classic and elegant yellow gold dress watch with a simple and timeless aesthetic. It’s priced at S$34,300 and currently retains more than half of its value as its market price falls at S$23,983.

3. Grand Complications Perpetual Calendar 5327G

Patek Philippe Grand Complications Perpetual Calendar 5327G

The 5327G is a white gold watch with a perpetual calendar complication, indicative of Patek Philippe’s technical prowess. It retails for S$149,800 and can be sold in the secondary market for S$89,110.

4. Aquanaut 5167A

Patek Philippe Aquanaut 5167A-001

This watch with a retail price of S$35,400 and a market value of S$67,397, is modern and sporty. It comes in stainless steel with a tropical rubber strap, appealing to a younger audience.

5. Calatrava 5226G

Patek Philippe Calatrava Ref. 5226G-001

This watch features a leather strap, a matching gradient dial, and contrasting dial details. This has a retail value of S$58,500 and a market price of S$52,076.

Cartier

Cartier, while also a luxury brand, has a more accessible pricing range of around S$2,797 to S$65,785. Cartier’s strategy involves catering to a broader audience by offering various products, including jewelry, leather goods, and watches, at various price points.

Here are some remarkable models from Cartier and their price points:

1. Tank Solo WSTA0028

Tank Solo WSTA0028

This contemporary interpretation of the classic Tank watch features a large rectangular stainless steel case, a Roman numeral dial, and a sapphire cabochon on the crown. It originally sells for S$3,489 but resells for up to S$4,635, as per the listings in Chrono24.

2. Ballon Bleu de Cartier W69012Z4

Ballon Bleu de Cartier W69012Z4

This distinctive timepiece retails for around S$8,757 with a maximum reselling price of S$30,310. Its most notable feature is the blue sapphire cabochon crown set in a protective arch, which gives the watch its name, “Ballon Bleu.”

3. Santos de Cartier WSSA0029

Santos de Cartier WSSA0029

This medium-sized model was originally valued at S$8,957 and can sell for up to S$25,492. It maintains the signature square bezel with visible screws and a classic Roman numeral dial.

4. Drive de Cartier WSNM0004

cartier watch-WSNM0004

This watch is characterized by its cushion-shaped case and domed crystal. The silvered flinqué dial with Roman numerals and the blued-steel sword-shaped hands contribute to its elegant appearance. This retails for S$8,800 and has a market value of S$4,877.

5. Cle de Cartier WSCL0007

Cle de Cartier WSCL0007

Known for its key-like precision setting crown, the Cle de Cartier features a 40mm round case with a clean and minimalist design. The watch has a silvered flinqué dial, blue sword-shaped hands, and a date aperture. This can set you back to S$7,800 from a dealer or S$4,904 from a market dealer.

So Which Is Better?

Patek Philippe and Cartier excel in different aspects: Patek for technical precision and investment value, Cartier for bold design and accessibility.

AspectPatek PhilippeCartier
Heritage and History• Founded in 1839 in Geneva, Switzerland
• Known for technical innovation and precision
• Established in 1847 in Paris, France
• Initially a jewelry house, ventured into watchmaking in 1904
Design Philosophy and Aesthetics• Refined and classic appearance
• Round or slightly curved cases. Clean, uncluttered dials with Roman or baton hour markers
• Subtle color palette
• Distinctive and bold designs
• Unique case shapes like rectangular Tank, square Santos, and oval Baignoire
• Dials with Roman numerals, blued-steel hands, and signature guilloché pattern
• Varied color palette
Craftsmanship and Technical Excellence• Meticulous handcrafting process
• Limited production numbers
• High-quality materials
• Creative design approach.
• Development of unique watch mechanisms
• Precise setting of gemstones
Innovations and Horological Achievements• First pocket watch with a tourbillon
• Development of the perpetual calendar mechanism
• Creation of the mystery clock
• Development of in-house movements like the Calibre de Cartier
Price PointsS$14,299 to S$790,636S$2,797 to S$65,785
Investment ValueS$5,156 to S$10,955,425S$374 to S$1,446,943

Celebrities and Popular People Who Wear Patek and Cartier

When you enter the world of Patek Philippe, you’re in the company of royalty and A-list celebrities. After all, it’s a brand synonymous with prestige and luxury. 

Here’s a list of celebrities and popular people who wear Patek Philippe watches:

Celebrities and popular people who wear Patek Philippe watches
  • Jay Z
  • Drake
  • Brad Pitt
  • Kevin Hart
  • Ed Sheeran
  • John Mayer
  • Charlie Sheen
  • Angelina Jolie
  • Leonardo DiCaprio
  • Robert Lewandowski

Meanwhile, here are some popular figures seen flaunting a Cartier watch:

Popular figures seen flaunting a Cartier watch
  • Finneas
  • Dan Levy
  • Rami Malek
  • Jeremy Piven
  • Jason Momoa 
  • Jeff Goldblum
  • Henry Golding
  • Tom Hiddleston
  • Jake Gyllenhaal
  • Robert Pattinson

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is Patek Better Than Cartier?

Patek Philippe is often perceived as the pinnacle of fine watchmaking due to its complex, high-quality movements and exclusivity. If you’re looking for an investment piece, Patek might be your choice. In contrast, Cartier offers a blend of luxury and relatively more accessible pricing, making it a brand with a broader appeal.

2. Is Cartier Considered a Luxury Watch?

Yes, Cartier is indeed considered a luxury watch brand. Its reputation is built on a foundation of quality craftsmanship and timeless designs. Their iconic Tank Solo, for instance, is a testament to their tireless dedication to elegance and style without being as pricey as Rolex, Audemars, Piguet, or Patek Philippe compared to other luxury watchmakers.

3. Is Patek Philippe the Most Expensive Luxury Watch Brand?

While not singularly the most expensive, Patek Philippe is among the top-tier brands that command high prices for their timepieces. In fact, according to Business Insider, a Patek Philippe Sky Moon Tourbillon was sold at a virtual Christie’s auction in Hong Kong for a whopping S$7,754,484.

This should be no surprise as the brand’s exquisite watches are seen as statements of wealth and status, crafted in limited quantities, which boosts their value and desirability.

4. Is Patek Philippe the Best Watch in the World?

“Best” is subjective, but Patek Philippe is frequently listed among the best regarding craftsmanship, heritage, and prestige. They offer high-quality and valuable timepieces often cherished by watch collectors and watch enthusiasts globally.

Final Word

Patek Philippe stands out for its technical excellence, timeless elegance, and high investment value, appealing to those seeking exclusivity and precision in watchmaking. Conversely, Cartier distinguishes itself with bold, innovative designs and a focus on blending fine jewelry with watch artistry, offering more accessible luxury while maintaining a strong investment appeal.

Key Takeaways

  • Patek Philippe embodies technical innovation and timeless elegance, while Cartier offers bold, innovative designs blending fine jewelry and watchmaking artistry.
  • Patek Philippe showcases meticulous handcrafting and complicated movements, symbolizing exclusivity and precision. Though less technically advanced, Cartier displays creative design approaches and innovative movements, blending technical ingenuity with aesthetic elegance.
  • Patek Philippe commands higher prices due to exclusivity and limited production, often appreciated as investment pieces. Cartier offers more accessible luxury, maintaining investment value while appealing to a broader audience.

Looking to buy or sell your luxury watches? Watch Exchange is your one-stop destination for trading RolexPatek Philippe, Tissot, Sinn, Zenith, and other luxury timepieces. Find your next watch today or list your item for free!


Buy or Trade Sell or Consign